OneWillRead

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

800 Words: Why Religion Always Wins - Part 1

Posted on 10:38 PM by Unknown

I’ve long since resigned myself to militant agnosticism and can’t help a seething contempt for anyone who’d care enough about God to take a stand on what God is. There are times in my life when I’ve believed in God, fervently, there were also times when my atheism was utterly complete. At the moment, I’m not sure I believe in God – but if I do, then I believe She’s a massive bitch.

I am not an atheist, I am an anti-theist. It’s not that I believe there is no God, it’s that I am against God. God is a bloodthirsty dictator who takes as much pleasure in killing those who try to obey his word as those who don’t. He sees all, hears all thoughts, yet She never seems to intervene except in the heads of His insane prophets, who inevitably tell their charges that God wants them to ostracize, mutilate, and kill far more often than to heal and help. I am against the Jewish deity I was raised to believe in that killed six million who in living memory worshiped within his temples, I am against a deity of all men who would allow more billions of his humble servants to be slaughtered millennium by millennium; all by the same war, poverty, and by other people's mental derangement which She never feels any need to cure. And then there are the lucky few among us, like me, fortunate enough to be born in peacetime. Those of us lucky enough to die in peacetime of natural causes will mostly do so in slow, painful deaths over a period of decades.

Yet in spite of all of this, in spite of all evidence to the contrary that God is a force for totalitarian terror, His name persists through the eons as the font of all love and mercy. The more people to whom She causes suffering, the more people love Her. Every time mankind draws closer to an era of enlightened secularism, God works His avenging angels through His worshippers, and the greatness of civilization is brought down with an orgiastic holocaust of blood – the closer to a godless civilization mankind comes, the more bloody its downfall. For all this, and much more, I curse Him with all my heart, all my might, and all my soul.

Perhaps the very fact that humanity seems incapable of evolving past God is the ultimate evidence that She does exist. Man is a creature of belief, not doubt; he trusts everything from his mother’s breast to the nurse’s test-tubes. To endure life’s responsibilities, to build a civilization better for those who come after him, man requires a greater purpose – and there is no greater purpose than to redeem oneself by serving a Being who hears all thought, sees all action, and judges you accordingly.

Anyone who can still believe that such a being is capable of mercy is cruel himself, and anyone who would have us believe that another solution exists to make life less cruel – the worker’s paradise, the magic of science, the virtues of the free market – is no less cruel than the most dogmatic bible-thumper. Life has enough terrors in store without having to endure the misery of realizing that our consolations are false during our most desperate hours. If God is capable of saving us, then He simply refuses to do it. There is no evidence that God cares one way or another about the salvation of humanity. All that remains to redeem our world is the capricious and vice-plagued salvation of our peers. There is nothing with which we can fight our way out of savagery except to rely on other human beings, each as beastly, grotesque, and horrible as ourselves. Terrible as we are, only we can to protect those we love (and perhaps those we don’t as well) from as many miseries as possible. As for those from which we cannot be protected, we must endure our trials with as much bravery as we have the strength to bear.

And therefore, it is perhaps the cruelest of all life’s ironies that the best institution in humanity’s possession to protect one another is religion.

It’s nearly as terrible an irony that the same totalitarianism of thought which made so many religious people over the millennia want to kill one another could also encourage generosity and fealty to those with whom they share characteristics. If you believe existence precedes essence, then you believe the world to be a random place of chance encounters, nothing more. It therefore profits a man nothing to act virtuously, merely to act in self-interest. To put it more simply, those of us who believe that we are put on earth without purpose are at the ultimate disadvantage: if there is no dictator who judges our every action and thought, then the continuation and improvement of our world is no longer an unshakeable duty. We who love the secular world can pretend that the betterment of mankind is still every bit as much a duty, but it’s an incredibly stupid lie. If life is no longer a gift from a creator who will punish us if we do not acknowledge Him, then we can discard its contents at our pleasure.

Therefore, even if there is only evolution in the hand of the world’s creation, then religious people are still at a huge evolutionary advantage from the rest of us. Their world has purpose we lack, they have an end goal in sight for what their lives must achieve – and they have millions of peers who share their goal. Most importantly, their desire for a better life makes them have more children who then can then be taught to covet the same end.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in 800 Words, Religion, Why Religion Always Wins | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • 800 Words: My Cultural Heresies - Middle-Aged Movies (Part 2)
    -           George Lucas should never have made another Star Wars movie after A New Hope. He should have just filmed Apocalypse Now (origina...
  • 800 Words: Vitality
    It was a great weekend I just spent in Cape Cod, and for the entirety of it my body felt like feces incarnate. I hadn’t gotten a good night’...
  • 800 Words: The Failed Classical Revolution - Part 3
    Another week passes, and I’m still the director of Kol Rinah. If you have musical ability, there really isn’t much to being a good conductor...
  • The Magic of Isaiah Berlin
    Everyone should listen to and read as many of his lectures as possible. This one in particular, and the book that was collected from it, The...
  • Sunday Playlist: Sun Records
    The Memphis Record Label that founded Rock'n Roll (at least the white half... maybe I can find a Chess Records playlist for the other ha...
  • Sight and Sound Movie List - Richard Nixon
    I don't watch movies for enjoyment. I don't watch them to escape. I watch them to atone. #1: JFK   (1991, dir. Oliver Stone) Kennedy...
  • 800 Words: That Paper from Yesterday, Better Formatted (let's try this again)
    Here it is again...sans footnotes and hopefully formatted better. Jeane J. Kirkpatrick: The Masquerade of Conservative Idealism as ...
  • 800 Words: The Disorganized Imagination of Leos Janacek
    I have a mind that goes into overdrive all too easily. I find that if I don’t write something – something long - every day, I spend whole ho...
  • 800 Words: Culture of Offense
    Jason Alexander is not Michael Richards, after spending my youth watching Seinfeld on loop, I can tell you definitively that Michael Richard...
  • 800 Words & Friday Playlist: The Fantasy World of Wagner’s Ring Part 1
    (If I told you that this music is about planning a wedding, would you believe me?) I still don’t get it. No matter how much I vow to stay aw...

Categories

  • 10 Years Ago (1)
  • 10 Years Ago... (2)
  • 800 Words (146)
  • A Post-Wedding Brunch Fight About Barbara Jordan (2)
  • Aaron Sorkin (3)
  • Almanac (6)
  • assimilation (1)
  • Bach (1)
  • Bad Culture (1)
  • Ballet (2)
  • baltimore (2)
  • Beethoven (2)
  • Benny Goodman (1)
  • Berlin Philharmonic (3)
  • Berlioz (2)
  • best of the year 2012 (4)
  • Bob Dylan (1)
  • books (8)
  • Brahms (1)
  • Breaking Bad (1)
  • Carl Sagan (1)
  • Choral Music (1)
  • Christian Thielemann (1)
  • Colin Davis (1)
  • Comedy (3)
  • Daniel Barenboim (2)
  • Daniele Gatti (1)
  • Dave Brubeck (1)
  • David Bowie (1)
  • Dialogues (4)
  • Dreams of My Mother (3)
  • Duke Ellington (2)
  • Dvorak (1)
  • Elton John (1)
  • Eric Hoffer (1)
  • Fiction (2)
  • football (1)
  • Frank Martin (1)
  • Friday Playlist (34)
  • Gennadi Rozhdestvensky (1)
  • Giovanni Verga (1)
  • Goethe (1)
  • Golijov (1)
  • Guest Post (25)
  • gunther schuller (1)
  • Happiness - The Mortal Enemy (3)
  • history (38)
  • Isaiah Berlin (2)
  • Israel (5)
  • Italo Svevo (1)
  • James Levine (1)
  • Janacek (2)
  • Jazz (7)
  • Jewish Intolerance (4)
  • Judaism (12)
  • karl bohm (1)
  • Larry David (1)
  • Leonard Bernstein (3)
  • Les Miserables (2)
  • Louis Armstrong (2)
  • Louis CK (2)
  • Mad Men (2)
  • Mahler (1)
  • Marvin Hamlisch (1)
  • mengelberg (1)
  • Middle East (4)
  • mini-essays (4)
  • Movies (9)
  • Mozart (1)
  • Mstislav Rostropovich (1)
  • Musical Obituaries (6)
  • Must See TV (2)
  • My Cultural Heresies (7)
  • My Favorite Album (22)
  • Neil Young (1)
  • Non-Classical Music (44)
  • Obama (7)
  • opera (3)
  • Otis Redding (1)
  • Paavo Jarvi (2)
  • philosophy (14)
  • Poetry (1)
  • Politics (43)
  • Pollini (1)
  • Quote of the Day (11)
  • ragtime (1)
  • Random Youtube Crap (4)
  • Randy Newman (1)
  • Ravel (1)
  • Ray Charles (1)
  • Religion (22)
  • Riccardo Chailly (1)
  • Rolling Stone's Top 50 (3)
  • Roosevelt (2)
  • Schubert (2)
  • Schutz (1)
  • Science (3)
  • scott joplin (1)
  • Seinfeld (3)
  • Semyon Bychkov (1)
  • Shakespeare (1)
  • Sight and Sound Movie List (21)
  • Simon Rattle (2)
  • songs (1)
  • Soul: The American Music (2)
  • Star Wars (1)
  • Stephen Sondheim (3)
  • Stravinsky (1)
  • Sufjan Stevens (1)
  • The American Utopia (2)
  • The Best Songwriter There Is (1)
  • The Eurasian Faultline (2)
  • The Failed Classical Revolution (2)
  • The Middle East (5)
  • The Productivity of Suffering (3)
  • The Sopranos (1)
  • theater (7)
  • Thomas Beecham (1)
  • To My 19 and 24 Year Old Political Selves (6)
  • Travel (8)
  • TV (7)
  • Verdi (1)
  • vienna philharmonic (1)
  • Visual Art (2)
  • Vladimir Jurowski (1)
  • Wagner (3)
  • Werner Herzog (1)
  • What Inspires You (4)
  • Why Impressionism is a Buzzkill (2)
  • Why Religion Always Wins (4)
  • Why Violence (1)
  • Wilhelm Furtwangler (1)
  • Woody Allen (1)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (126)
    • ►  September (4)
    • ►  August (9)
    • ►  July (14)
    • ►  June (15)
    • ►  May (34)
    • ►  April (13)
    • ►  March (12)
    • ►  February (14)
    • ►  January (11)
  • ▼  2012 (174)
    • ►  December (15)
    • ►  November (18)
    • ►  October (15)
    • ►  September (23)
    • ►  August (9)
    • ►  July (15)
    • ►  June (32)
    • ▼  May (47)
      • Friday Playlist #16: Random Vaguely Bluegrass Them...
      • Dancing in the Streets
      • 800 Words: My Cultural Heresies - History (part 1)
      • 800 Words: Why Early Music Sucks
      • 800 Words: My Cultural Heresies Part 1: Classical ...
      • 800 Words: Why Religion Always Wins - Part III
      • Quote of the Day
      • Friday Playlist #15 - Hungarian Brahms
      • Quote of the Day:
      • Sight and Sound Movie List: The Manning
      • 800 Words: The Eurasian Faultline: Part 2 - Athens...
      • Quote of the Day:
      • 800 Words: The Eurasian Faultline - Part I: Istanbul
      • Sight and Sound Movie List: The Treff/Liang
      • The Frank Martin Mass
      • Quote of the Day
      • Sight and Sound Movie List: Il Barone
      • 800 Words: For DFD (1925-2012)
      • Sight and Sound Movie List - El Aguirre
      • ET: Almanac
      • 800 Words: The Failed Classical Revolution - Part 3
      • RIP Chuck Brown Playlist
      • Sight and Sound Movie List - L'Olsen
      • 800 Words: Must See TV Part 1
      • Sight and Sound Movie List - Der Mazur
      • Quote of the Day
      • Sight and Sound Movie List - Der Miksic
      • 800 Words: Family Memory
      • Sight and Sound Epic List of the Awesomely Bad: Th...
      • Sight and Sound Movie List - Der Gronowski
      • Sight and Sound Film List: The Hicks
      • 800 Words: Why Religion Always Wins - Part 2
      • Sight and Sound Movie List: La Kozak
      • Sight and Sound Movie List - Die Grimes
      • Sight and Sound Movie List - Richard Nixon
      • Sight and Sound Movie List: HaZmora
      • Quote of the Day:
      • 800 Words: Why Religion Always Wins - Part 1
      • The McBee: Sight and Sound Movie List and Obnoxiou...
      • Sight and Sound Movie List - Der Koosh
      • Quote of the Day
      • Sight and Sound Movie List - Le Malon
      • Quote of the Day:
      • Sight and Sound Playlist - The McClure
      • Ambrose Akinmusire
      • Quote of the Day:
      • Early Friday Playlist (#14): Der Fersko's Sight an...
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile